Formula1.com: Not Partisan At All!
So, I guess Formula1.com, official FIA corporate shills website for F1 has made their rooting interests known to all. Here's a screenshot from today's front page:
Yep, that's Slappy, staring majestically at the address bar... and, no, usually the page color isn't Ferrari Red.
One gets the feeling that if, say, David Coulthard's Chin or Jack Newtown made a triumphant return to F1, they wouldn't get a banner on the front page... Could we be a little less blatant, guys?
1
Return of Coulthard is non-news because he didn't win 7 championships. Please. Instead of exposing somebody's else biases you succeed in showing yours.
Posted by: Pete Zaitcev at August 01, 2009 04:33 AM (/ppBw)
2
The difference is, Pete, that I'm not afraid to show my biases. The FIA claims to be impartial, and should be, yet obviously isn't.
I'll be blunt. Promoting any one driver, any one team, by changing the official website of the sport, so that any visitor is slammed with it, is ridiculous.
Unless they change it again, so tomorrow it's Lewis Hamilton's face up there, or HWMNBN, or even Adrian Sutil, it's just another sloppy blowjob being given to Ferrari.
Posted by: Wonderduck at August 01, 2009 08:28 AM (VosBh)
3
Sung to the tune "Stormy Weather"
"Don't know why I've got lipstick on my fly.
Sloppy blowjob."
I suppose that's going to be Ferrari red lipstick?
Posted by: toadold at August 01, 2009 10:17 AM (TPodH)
4
It's pure marketing, just like many of the other things that you find annoying about the sport. Even my father, who follows racing not at all, heard that Schumi was returning and was interested enough to call me and ask for details and my opinion. For the FIA not to try and capitalize on that kind of interest would be criminally stupid.
None of which proves that they aren't biased of course, I just don't think that's the driving force here.
Posted by: David at August 01, 2009 05:32 PM (n/RK7)
His point is well taken. In the end, the only real difference between Vince McMahon and Bernie Ecclestone is that McMahon makes no pretense of running a fair game. The WWF is entertainment first and foremost.
I don't believe that the F1 races are fixed, of course, but F1 isn't a non-profit and disinterested sports ajudication group. It's a for-profit entertainment company, and attracting attention from paying fans is job #1.
BMW Out, Slappy In! And Other News (UPDATED)
Busy day in the F1 world!
BMW announced that they would be withdrawing from Formula 1 racing effective at the end of the current season. The company restructured their entire motorsports division, citing a desire to "dedicate more resources to developing new, sustainable road car technologies."
The German manufacturer took over the Sauber-Petronas team in 2006, and in 2008 finished second in the Constructor's Championship, behind Ferrari (McLaren were excluded, otherwise they would have finished 2nd). The team's shining moment would have been the 2008 Canadian Grand Prix, when they got their first victory behind Robert Kubica, with Grizzly Nick Heidfeld finishing second. 2009 has been a horror story for them, however, earning only eight points to date.
At the moment, it is unknown what BMW is going to do with the team's infrastructure: sell it off, much like SuperAguri did, or attempt to spin it away in one piece, like Honda did with their team (now BrawnGP). This all came as a surprise to Grizzly Nick, who said on his website "BMW's decision no longer to compete in Formula
One was totally unexpected. I feel
very sorry for the members of the team with whom it has been my
privilege to work over the years. I would like to thank all of them for
their tremendous support and for everything we have achieved together."
Unless another BrawnGP-like resurrection occurs, expect Kubica and Heidfeld to be in quite a bit of demand during the "silly season". After all, Manor Motorsports needs drivers...
In the other bit of surprising news, god help us all, Michael "Slappy" Schumacher is back.
The birth of "Slappy"
With Ferrari making the intelligent decision to keep the injured Felipe Massa out of the cockpit for the rest of the season, the team needed a replacement driver for the second half of the season. The team's test drivers, Luca Badoer and Marc Gene, would have to be called merely serviceable: both have driven in F1, though not since 2004 (Gene) and 1999 (Badoer). And there's that little thing about seven world championships.
I find it ironic that I may have brought this upon us. Just a few days ago, in a post dealing with the FIA SuperLicense, I mentioned that if the FIA votes unanimously to give a driver a license, he can be given one without meeting any of the requirements, then added "if Slappy Schumacher was hired to drive a F1 car again, that's how he'd qualify, I'm sure." When will I learn?
Anyway, Slappy will be undergoing a special training program to prepare for his first race back, at Valencia in a month. Not that he's out of shape, particularly for a 40-year-old, but he hasn't driven a F1 car in anger since he retired in 2006. If nothing else, his neck muscles have to be built up in a hurry to deal with the g-forces. He has never driven Ferrari's current car, and with the testing ban in place, he won't get to until Friday practice for Valencia. Still, there's that little thing about seven world championships...
...and at least the Official First Reader of The Pond, Mallory, will be happy.
Finally, it's pretty safe to say that while Renault may not be on-track due to their penalty in Hungary, Nelson Piquet Unemployed will not be. Team boss Flavio Briatore said after the Hungarian Grand Prix that "...when a driver lacks results, he opens the book of
excuses and begins: the fault is the weather's, a spectator's
sunglasses, a spin on the straight, this and that...
I expected more from Nelson."
Piquet's response was somewhat... um... energetic: "Flavio is a business man, but he doesn't understand sh*t about F1." Now, we're not saying that Piquet is wrong, but that's never a good thing to say about your boss... particularly when it's true.
UPDATE: Felipe Massa was able to answer questions in three different languages (English, Portugese, and Italian) today. He also took his first steps since the accident, and will be transferred out of Intensive Care within the day. Docs are saying that he'll likely be discharged within two weeks. How cool is that?
Ferrari should just put Schumacher in the car and let him practice in it anyway, and dare F1 to slap them down. F1 would huff and puff, but there's no way they'll actually turn down such a lollipop as The Return Of Michael Schumacher.
Posted by: mparker762 at July 29, 2009 06:53 PM (arWhA)
2
Keeping Massa off the track for the rest of the season is unquestionably the right decision. Still, the medical news about him is very encouraging. Here's hoping for a complete recovery and a return to racing next year.
3
You know, it never really occurred to me that the drivers would need physical conditioning, but I guess it should have been obvious. I bet it takes a lot of hand and arm strength to really steer one of those, too.
4
You've gotta have a strong neck to deal with the g-forces pulling at your head (and helmet). Five Gs for a few seconds is bad enough, but five Gs for a few seconds three or four times a lap, times sixty laps...
And that's just the head. You've also got to be able to steer the car, control the gas pedal, make adjustments on the steering wheel, talk coherently to the crew on the pit wall, AND deal with 19 other cars, too.
Yeah, F1 drivers are usually in excellent physical shape. David Coulthard's Chin, in his 15 years as a driver, supposedly completed over 31000 hours of physical training, and that doesn't include wrist exercises for his autograph hand. That's nearly six hours a day, every day.
Posted by: Wonderduck at July 30, 2009 10:43 PM (ZpwKm)
5
There used to be times when Mansell had to be supported when he climbed out of the car, but I think he was the last champion who did not do much for physical conditioning. As the car performance continued to climb, so grew the fitness demands. With 5G sideways loads, it's pretty intense. Maybe not quite like Vegeta training in enhanced gravity chamber, but it goes there.
Posted by: Pete Zaitcev at July 30, 2009 10:47 PM (/ppBw)
RIP Merce Cunningham
The great modern/avant-garde dance choreographer Merce Cunningham passed away today at the age of 90. Considered one of the most influential choreographers of the 20th century, he was also one of the great dancers as well. He was a soloist with the Martha Graham Dance Company for six years before forming his own troupe.
In my prior life as a lighting designer, I did mostly plays and musicals. Whenever I was asked to design for a modern dance concert, though, I always lept at the chance. The apparent lack of structure to a modern dance piece let me play with techniques I wouldn't ever try during a play, simply because I was being graded on my "formal" designs.
I put "apparent" in italics up there because in many ways, modern dance is all about structure. Just like ballet, it is never, ever improved, though it is often hard to tell. There's a common symbolic language for modern dance that allows a choreographer to put a piece on paper, just like a score for an orchestra. Nowadays, it's done via computer programs, of course.
But that structure was less confining than the traditional ballet style, letting a choreographer pull off some amazing things. Because of that, I LOVED designing for dance. It was really the only time that I, as a designer, felt like I was one of the performers.
Usually in a stage production (with some rare exceptions), the best lighting designs are the ones you never notice... kinda like a baseball umpire. It may take hundreds or thousands of hours to accomplish, but the lights are there to make the actors look good, not to make themselves look good.
With modern dance, however, lighting is there to accompany the dancers on-stage, sometimes literally. I remember one senior dance project I worked on when I was in grad school where the choreographer wanted a duet on stage: one physical dancer, and the lights were the other 'dancer'. She came to me before she started anything and asked for my opinions and input... and I was thrilled. It was a bear to pull off with limited resources, but we made it work.
Modern dance allows you to do things like that. While Cunningham's style was much closer to ballet than, say, Twyla Tharp's, and not for everyone's tastes, he was still one of the great innovators of a style of art that I love.
Massa's Condition Update III
Some grim news came out of Hungary this afternoon as it was announced that Felipe Massa was still suffering from swelling of the brain. That's bad enough, and explains why he'd been in a medically-induced coma for so long, but the really horrible news is that the Brazilian may have suffered damage to his left eye.
If that is the case, and he can't recover whatever vision is lost, then this incident may very well have ended his F1 career.
The doctors are saying that it'll be at least a week before they can judge whether or not Massa has suffered any impairment from the brain damage, though they did take him off the ventilator and pulled him out of the coma. He'll remain in intensive care for the forseeable future, however.
1
Grim news, indeed, especially the news about the eye injury.
Posted by: Mallory at July 28, 2009 10:08 AM (WJ2qy)
2
John Smith, if you want to break news, please do it on your own blog. Unfortunately, I do have to work, so I can't sit 24/7 on the F1 news. Rest assured, I will post about it when I get a chance.
Posted by: Wonderduck at July 29, 2009 04:48 PM (ZpwKm)
Massa's Condition Update II
Even better: he is now able to move his hands and legs, and is "actively communicating", said Hungarian Defense Ministry spokesman Istvan Bocskai. That would suggest that there isn't significant brain damage.
Ferrari president Luca di Montezemelo is supposed to pay him a visit today. Despite this, Felipe Massa's condition is expected to improve.
1
It's good to hear that he's getting better. But if everyone's smart, he won't race again this season. An injury like this isn't something to laugh off.
F1 Update!: Hungary 2009!
We admit that we're writing this while the race is still running on FOX. The ending doesn't seem to be in doubt, and it's been a pretty dull race for the most part. THIS is your F1 Update! for the Hungarian Grand Prix!
*MISSING MAN FORMATION: There was never any question but that Felipe Massa wasn't driving this race, but we were surprised to hear that Ferrari wouldn't field a second car.
*ALL BETS ARE OFF: It's now a free-for-all for the Driver's Championship. With Seb Vettel retiring from the race and Mark Webber finishing third, suddenly Webbo is second in the points. Throw in Button finishing a weak 7th and Rubens Barrichello's customary bad getaway at the start forcing him to scramble for 10th place, and we're starting to get a little tighter in the Constructor's Championship, too. Suddenly, however, the 600lb gorilla known as McLaren have to be considered in the running for something with their runaway victory and 5th place finish. About the only thing we feel safe to call is that Farce India won't win either championship.
*DRIVER OF THE RACE: "The car has come alive. I can win with it now." Those were the words of Lewis Hamilton back before the the German Grand Prix, and perhaps it was only because of his bump in the first turn of that race that he couldn't make them come true then. But he has now. Once he got past Mark Webber for second (see below), it was pretty clear that he was going to be running the show. Once HWMNBN removed himself from the lead for a pitstop on lap 11, it was clear sailing for Hamilton, who turned in one of his usual flawless runs from the front.
*TEAM OF THE RACE: McLaren. 1st and 5th for a team that looked like it was more likely to be dicing with the Farce Indias for 20th at the start of the season? They're back, and they're ready to take over.
*MOVE OF THE RACE: On lap 5, Hamilton was dueling with Mark Webber coming down the front straight, neither driver giving an inch as they rocketed towards turn 1. Webber had the middle of the track staked out, and Hamilton swung to the outside, looking like he was going to try to outbrake the Red Bull. Instead, he slowed early, cut to the inside of the Aussie, then jammed his finger down on the KERS button and flew away. Totally effortless, and there wasn't a darn thing Webber could do about it, save for wrecking both cars.
*MOOOOOO-OOOVE OF THE RACE: In a repeat of the 2006 Hungarian Grand Prix, HWMNBN came into the pits for fuel and a tire change. Unfortunately, the chief engineer gave the two-time champion the okay to go before everything was finished being tightened down. The result?
For the record, a F1 car loses a lot of grip when there are tires on only three corners. Congratulations, Renault, not only do you get the MOOOotR, but you've also been suspended for the European Grand Prix for "allowing HWMNBN to leave the pits with a wheel not properly secured." Good jorb!
HWMNBN must have been livid. After pulling out his first pole of the year, to flush it away like that because of a mistake by the pit crew just have been disappointing as all hell.
2
Great run by Button yesterday, who deserved the win solely for his exchange with HWMNBN live on BBC on Saturday after the timing went down. Button: I did 1:22.5, what about you? HWMNBN: 1:21.7 Button: F***ing Hell!
Also after that terrible accident to Massa, I believe that Ferrari couldn't run a replacement, saw discussion of this elsewhere, and it seems to be that the rules state you can't replace a driver after qualifying for the race starts.
Finally, rumour elsewhere is that a possible replacement for Massa for the next race could be...HWMNBN. Crazy rumour, but I wonder...
Posted by: flotsky at July 27, 2009 04:54 AM (BCXmT)
I was wondering if the replacement driver for Massa might be Schumacher, since The Chin has stepped back in from retirement. Also, it might make Massa feel better if his temporary replacement did not have designs on the driver's seat.
Posted by: Mallory at July 27, 2009 10:34 AM (WJ2qy)
Massa's Condition Update
Felipe Massa remains in a "life-threatening, but stable" state, and will be kept in a medically induced coma for the next 48 hours.
Peter Bazso, the medical director of the AEK Military Hospital in Budapest, also said that he's "in an acute phase. What can come next, we don't know." The good news is that there was no neurological damage and the results of brain scans were "encouraging." He will be given another CAT scan later today, according to the Ferrari press office.
Massa was woken up briefly so doctors could check on his condition and so he could see his family.
I think it's safe to say that he's probably going to be out for the rest of the season.
4
Well, according to the AP, he has an "open skull fracture", which according to allabouttbi.com puts him at high risk of infection. It may very well be, though, that they're worried because they had to remove pieces of his skull:
Peter Bazso, the AEK hospital medical director, told reporters that
Massa would remain sedated until Monday, but will be woken up
periodically during that time. When asked whether Massa's life remained in danger, Bazso answered: "Yes, of course." Bazso
said doctors were able to "remove the broken bones and stabilize the
area," which was necessary since Massa arrived with "an open skull
fracture and a contusion."
Removal of the broken bones is done to reduce pressure on a swelling brain. That's probably what they're concerned about, and if they haven't put in a temporary replacement to the missing pieces, his brain'll fall out.
As far as the Brawn disciplinary matter goes, I haven't heard or seen anything like that at all. The team was asked to check Jensen Button's car in the time between Q2 and Q3 yesterday, just to make sure that it wasn't a design problem inherent to the Brawns. As a result, he didn't get to take to the track until half the 3rd session was over. The FIA technical nabobs let him go, so they seem to think it was just an unlucky racing incident.
Barrichello was four seconds ahead of Massa on the track, and around a corner from him to boot. It's amazing to think that that spring bounced along on the racing line right where Massa wound up.
Is it possible that Brawn'll get penalized? I no longer think it ISN'T possible, because who really knows what the FIA'll do anymore? But I think the chances of it are slim. At worst, they'll be forced to redesign that portion of their car, much as Red Bull had to do to their front suspension last year.
Posted by: Wonderduck at July 26, 2009 07:37 PM (ZpwKm)
However, that's all secondary. Felipe Massa was involved in a very hard crash right towards the end of Q2. At first, it was thought that there was some malfunction with the car, as tiremarks showed that he never even tried to make the turn at Turn 4, and went straight into the barrier at Turn 5.
Then came the news that Rubens Barrichello, who went out in Q2, was hampered by rear suspension problems: something important, but not crippling, came off the suspension, something called a damper spring, which is the F1 version of a shock absorber. It weighs about two pounds and is made of steel, "about the size of a microphone" as the BBC reporter put it.
Then came the video:
Felipe Massa was last known to be in "serious, life-threatening, but stable condition", after requiring surgery to fix a skull fracture, cuts to his chin and forehead, and a concussion. He was sedated and on a respirator, in intensive care, and was expected to be woken up on Sunday morning. Obviously, he's out of the Hungarian Grand Prix, and may be out of the next race in four weeks. The latest news is that his life is no longer in danger.
Uh-oh. When I looked at the F1 site this afternoon, they were saying that Massa was just shaken up. They even suggested that it was possible he might drive tomorrow.
Man; I had no idea it was so bad. I'm glad he's not going to die, though.
If Vettel keeps doing as good as he has been, and Button as poorly, Button's lead in the driver championship could be in serious peril. He's only 21 points ahead of Vettel now.
2
Watching qualifying this morning, the gravity of the accident didn't hit me until I saw the slow-motion film of that suspension component striking Massa in the head. I know it's been 15 years since Senna was killed... and as I sat here with tears in my eyes, I realized that I'm just not ready for another death. Media is reporting that he had a skull fracture in the forhead area and a basal skull fracture. The object tore the visor out of the helmet and left a long gash down the side of the helmet. Chances are that the basal skull fracture could have been caused by the impact with the wall. If so, the HANS device may have saved his life. My prayers are with him.
Posted by: madmike at July 25, 2009 10:44 PM (9+cXm)
3
Mike, I knew it was bad when the cameras cut away from the accident site after a track marshal did the "crossed arms X". It seems the FIA uses the same indicator as World Wrestling Entertainment for a "legit" injury.
I haven't seen the report of a basal skull fracture. If he DID suffer one, he's remarkably lucky to be alive: that's the same injury that killed Roland Ratzenberger during that terrible weekend and Dale Earnhardt Sr.
Steven, until the report comes out saying that he'll make a full recovery, I'm not taking anything for granted concerning his life. Fortunately, medical science has come a long way when it comes to brain injuries and it's not likely he'll die. However, in 1975 there was an American driver named Mark Donohue. He crashed in a practice session, and while he seemed fine at the time, he died the next day of a cerebral hemmorage after complaining of a headache.
I hope that, in this case, the surgery Massa has already undergone took care of that possibility.
Posted by: Wonderduck at July 25, 2009 11:23 PM (ZpwKm)
"At the time he was admitted to [the] hospital his condition was stable and he was breathing and blood circulation was normal," the Hungarian defense department said in a statement. "During the course of his examination they established that he suffered serious, life-threatening injuries, including loss of consciousness and a fracture of the forehead on the left side and a fracture on the base of the skull."
5
I've seen the video, and you basically can't see the part at full speed, given how small it was and how fast everything was moving. But it's clear that it knocked Massa cold and he just continued in a straight line from that point into the wall. Fortunately it looked to me like his foot came off the gas and he was coasting for those 5-10 seconds, it could have been worse.
The concept of getting hit by a part at that speed is just frightening, and it's happening more often these days, some people are accusing the proliferation of carbon fibre for producing more fragments and weaker mounting points. I'm not sure what can be done to solve the issue or at least reduce the risk, but if anything can be done in terms of improved safety, F1 has a good history of figuring it out.
Posted by: David at July 26, 2009 12:01 AM (n/RK7)
As soon as I saw the track marshal do the crossed armed "X" I wondered if it meant the same thing as the WWE signal for a real injury. The fact that Massa wasn't moving was scary and put me in mind of the dark day that Dale Earnhardt, Sr., speared a wall in much the same way.
May prayers are with him and his family during his recovery.
Posted by: Mallory at July 26, 2009 10:13 AM (WJ2qy)
DuckFest 2009 Is Today!
The 7th annual meeting for rubber duckie collectors, DuckFest 2009, is taking place in New York City today.
...and I'm not there.
I am sad.
The owner and operator of The Duck Show, Digicolleen, is the host of this year's convention, and I'm sure there will be tons of pictures posted over the coming days. She's also where I ganked the above photo, but I know she won't mind.
Have fun, everybody... next year, I'll finally meet you!
F1 Quals: Hungary 2009 Will Be Even More Delayed
Last night's thunderstorms have, apparently, done something bad to Pond Central's satellite feed, or SPEED is trying to clear dead crows out of its antennae, or something, because I'm just getting a black screen with choppy voice during today's coverage of the Hungarian Quals.
I'm pretty sure it's on SPEED's end, because none of my other channels are affected.
So I'll either have to d/l coverage, further delaying the F1 Quals report, or I can just go and base it all off of coverage from the F1 website, which is cheating.
It seems like even the weathergods have a problem with Hungary. The 2007 Hungarian GP is the only race I've missed in five years.
F1 Practice: Hungary 2009!
Much to my surprise, the Legendary Announce Team was on a "Hungary is a really good track" kick today during P2. "Because of the terrain (the Hungaroring is built in the valley of three hills) It's a great place to watch the race." "The race always gives us some special memory." "It's a driver's track."
But yet, after the first lap there's usually no action to speak of, the drivers hate it, and it's more of a destruction test than a race at times. No, I'm going to go out on a limb here and disagree with the L.A.T.: it's a horrible track.
On track, there wasn't much to report. Oh, the Ferraris were having serious problems with grip again, and Felipe Massa in particular looked like he was driving on an ice rink, but they've had those problems before, too. McLaren were on top of the timesheets all day. Heikki Kovaleininninninnie was fastest until the final second or so, when Lewis Hamilton turned in the quick lap of the session. The very interesting result, though, was that the entire field back to 17th place was separated by just one second. That's pretty tight, and makes Quals look particularly exciting.
In other news, the New Kid On The Track (NKOTT), Toro Rosso's Jaime Alguersuari has been at the center of a firestorm of controversy. It turns out that, before today, he had turned a grand total of ZERO laps ever in a Formula 1 car. He's done some straight-line runs (which are all that are allowable under the regulations), but not even many of those. He earned his FIA SuperLicense, without which one cannot drive in F1, by winning last year's British Formula 3 championship.
There are many ways to earn a SuperLicense. Winning or being in the top three of some FIA-sponsored series (Formula 3, GP2, F3000, etc), or finishing in the top six of the Indy Racing League or CART can earn you one. Driving 300km in a F1 car at race speeds within 2 days can, with approval of the FIA, earn you one (this is how Fast Yuji Ide earned his provisional SuperLicense). You can also be granted one by unanimous vote by the FIA license board, but that's not very common... if Slappy Schumacher was hired to drive a F1 car again, that's how he'd qualify, I'm sure.
Many drivers have mentioned that NKOTT is going to be something of a risk out there. Nobody doubts he has the skillset to be a F1 driver, just that he doesn't have the experience. I tend to be more of the "If you're good enough, you're experienced enough" school of thought (see Vettel, Sebastian, US Grand Prix, 2007), but the drivers certainly have the right to voice their concerns. And, for the record, NKOTT was dead last on the timesheets today, 1.8 seconds behind.
Finally, BMW had something weird on their car during Practice 1 today. Take a look:
Look directly in front of the driver.
At first, the LAT speculated that the team neglected to remove the platform that the team places a video monitor on when the car is in the garage. The monitor allows the driver to see telemetry, replays, or even the FIA video feed, but usually the base is designed to sit on the bodywork directly, no 'table' needed.
Eventually, the LAT's tech wonk, Steve Matchett, suggested that perhaps it's something related to testing for the 2010 car. Since there's no testing allowed outside of race weekend, he said, maybe the 'table' is to simulate the design of the bodywork for next year's chassis, so as to check sightlines and visibility over the nose. "After all, it'd be a bad thing if you put the driver in the car and he says 'it feels great, but I can't see anything'!"
Certainly there's no way the aerodynamic techies would let something like that hit the track, what with that flat front screwing up airflow! It wasn't there in P2, so it seems like Matchett has the right of it, or at least is in the neighborhood.
Quals tomorrow morning. Unfortunately, I'm working at the Duck U. Bookstore in the morning, then having lunch with Momzerduck and Ph.Duck afterwards, so don't look for the report to be up until the evening. See ya then!
UPDATE: Almost forgot the most important news! David Coulthard's Chin has been rehired by Red Bull as the team's third driver, replacing NKOTT. This means that if Mark Webbo or Seb Vettel get sick, or injured, or are otherwise unable to race, The Chin will be back!
1
Sounds more like a pocket review of <i>V for Vendetta</i> in a put-on German accent.
Was this the director's cut version I've been hearing about? I was a little down on the first-run version they were showing last spring.
Posted by: Mitch H. at July 23, 2009 07:56 AM (jwKxK)
2
It was the Director's Cut, yes. I never saw the first-run, so I have no idea which scenes were added to the DVD (except for the death of Hollis Mason, which fact I stumbled over earlier tonight).
I was quite impressed with Watchmen.
Posted by: Wonderduck at July 23, 2009 07:59 AM (ZpwKm)
3
I've still only seen the first trailer. The first trailer was awesome though.
And I've read the comic, of course. Didn't like it, but read it.
Posted by: Pixy Misa at July 26, 2009 09:26 AM (PiXy!)
4
Pixy, I don't know that anybody liked Watchmen, the comic. It's not that sort of comic, y'know? Impressed by it, admired it, blown away by it, yeah. But liked?
The story is too ugly to like.
I'd recommend the movie to anybody who has read the series. I'm unsure about anybody else, though.
Posted by: Wonderduck at July 26, 2009 10:21 AM (ZpwKm)
I liked it, mostly. The pirate segments went on for too long (and I'm glad those were cut out of the movie) but for me it was Rorschach that really made the comic for me.
He's really a fascinating character. And despite how despicable he is, in many ways, there are other ways in which he's really very admirable. In particular, "Never compromise."
F1 on TV: Hungary 2009
It's twisty, it's slow, it's dull, and it's not Monaco? Then it must be Hungary!
Here's the trackmap... look at it and weep:
Occasionally called "Monaco without the glamour", the Hungaroring is one of the slowest tracks on the F1 schedule. With only one turn that could remotely be called fast (#10, and even that's a nearly-90o bend), and one of the shortest straights on the calendar (only 700m), the main concept for the teams is to crank on as much wing as possible, coat the tires in superglue, and anything else they can think of to gain downforce. Five of the corners on this track are taken at about 60mph... that's a huge amount.
The slow speeds and usually hot air temperatures throw in another problem for the teams: cooling. Both the driver and the engine suffer mightily from the heat at Hungary. While there isn't much they can do for the man, don't be surprised if we see huge radiator ducts and cut-away body panels at the back of the car. Even then, we might see some overheating... unless it rains.
There's only one good passing spot here, Turn 1. Unfortunately, the slow speeds and the processional nature of the track generally render the Hungarian GP a snoozefest.
Fear not, fellow F1 fans! We here at F1 Update! will take one on the chin for you and deliver our usual stellar* performance for the race recap, so you won't miss a thing, and SPEED will do their usual good work on bringing us the sights.
They start off on Friday from 7am to 840am, with LIVE coverage of Friday's Second Practice. Skipping on to Saturday, from 7am to 830am we get plausibly live coverage of Quals.
On Sunday, however, we switch over to FOX (for the last time this season) from 2pm to 4pm for tape-delayed coverage of the Grand Prix of Hungary.
In other F1 news:
*As expected, Jamie Alguersuari was officially named as the driver who gets SeaBass' recently vacated race seat at Toro Rosso. Just in time for the cars to get a much needed aero update... don't be surprised if the youngest driver in F1 history scores a point, and makes SeaBass look just that much worse.
*Danica Patrick recently told the LA Times that she's not interested in driving for USF1 next year. "I'd say it's probably not F1," she responded when asked what series she'd be racing in. "I've had opportunities to take it a step further with Formula
1, and I don't want to lead anyone down a path. It's not in my heart to
go there. I've explored Europe before. I particularly like to be here and I like my family and I like my friends and I like my creature comforts of my home country." Unless Bernie Ecclestone, misogynistic gnome that he is, leaves the sport, we'll probably never see Patrick in a F1 car.
*There are reports that Nelson Piquet Jr needs a good showing at Hungary to save his seat. The official Renault press release for Hungary says that he's "targeting a top-10 grid spot and points in the race." After Hungary, F1 takes another three-week break, which would be an ideal time to kick Piquet to the curb. There's ominous music in the background...
*Max Mosley has officially stated (again) that he won't run for re-election as FIA President. Until we (metaphorically) see his body buried at the crossroads with a stake in his chest and his mouth full of garlic, I won't believe he's gone. Maybe not even then, if Jean Todt gets elected in his place.
*"stellar" in the same way that brown dwarfs and black holes could be called "stellar".
2
Because they (being the Hungarian gov'ment) pay Darth Bernie quite a lot for the right to host a GP. Nothing more, nothing less.
Silverstone is one of the most popular tracks ever in F1. The drivers love it, the teams love it, the fans love it... and because Bernie wants more money, Formula 1 is leaving to go someplace that (theoretically) will give Bernie what he wants.
Which is also why we have races in Abu Dhabi and Bahrain, by the way, and not Canada or the United States...
Posted by: Wonderduck at July 20, 2009 08:04 PM (ZpwKm)
3
I suppose I really should have known that without you having to tell me.
Piquet Jr is lucky he doesn't drive for Toro Roso. After a couple of weeks of rumors, SeaBass was gone, but that same "driving for his career" rumor has been hanging over Piquet's head for months now. Buh bye, already.
Any word on Zsolt?
Posted by: Mallory at July 21, 2009 02:30 PM (WJ2qy)
6
Haven't heard anything yet, but I'm hopeful for some exclusive news...
Posted by: Wonderduck at July 21, 2009 04:53 PM (ZpwKm)
Henry Surtees KilledHenry Surtees, 18-year-old son of F1 and motorsports legend John Surtees, was killed today while driving in a Formula 2 race at Brands Hatch, England.
During the second race of the weekend, Jack Clarke spun and smacked into the barrier outside of Westfield Bend. One of Clarke's rear wheels was torn from his car, where it rolled into the racing line just as Surtees swept by.
Surtees, in the blue & yellow car, was struck in the head by the tire and knocked unconscious. His car then drove straight on into the wall of the next turn, Sheene Corner, at 140mph. It took the first corner worker less than five seconds to reach him after the car came to a stop.
He was quickly extracted from the car and taken to the track's infield care center, where he was stabilized. He was then airlifted to Royal London Hospital, where he passed away a few hours later.
We here at F1 Update! extend our sincere condolences to the Surtees family.
It's especially sad because it wasn't his fault. It's not that he lost control of his car and hit something. He was just really, really unlucky and was in the wrong place at the wrong time.
3
"Ruptured Ducks"
Anything below the fold NSFW.
"Jeep Carriers"
The comic book series "Howard the Duck", not the movie
The US Navy's jet powered seaplane.
Humorous names for ships. (It was a space ship but I always liked "Frankly I blame the parents."
Ah. Then for "What if's" this post may inspire you.
I guess I would phrase it this way: In what at least semi-plausible scenario could the ME-262 actually have substantially affected the outcome of WWII?
(My own opinion is "there are none" but others may not agree with that. So suppose we discount the general answer that "If the war in Europe were still going on in August of 1945, the first A-bomb would have been dropped on Berlin" and go from there.)
7
If Hitler had been convinced that the Sturmvogel variant was a dog & stopped meddling, and if Göring hadn't choked off jet research early on, and if they had concentrated on just a few types instead of the myriad Wunderwaffen, there might have been enough ME-262s to knock back the daylight bombers.
Posted by: JP Gibb at July 19, 2009 07:55 AM (en+Q1)
8
What if the characters of Hidamari Sketch and Gurren Lagann traded places?
What if Go Nagai had directed Neon Genesis Evangelion?
What if Satoshi Kon had directed Lucky Star?
What if Haruhi Suzumiya had been made a decade earlier, and Megumi Hayashibara had been cast in the lead role?
Would anyone survive?
Posted by: Pixy Misa at July 19, 2009 08:11 AM (PiXy!)
9If Hitler had been convinced...(snip)...there might have been enough ME-262s to knock back the daylight bombers.
Well, so much for that post.
Posted by: Wonderduck at July 19, 2009 10:31 AM (ZpwKm)
As penance: If Japan had a heavy bomber comparable to the B-29, could we have won the Pacific theater?
Posted by: JP Gibb at July 19, 2009 11:08 AM (en+Q1)
11
The thing that probably hurt Japanese air power the most was the lack of engine design and development and the ability to mass produce the complex multi bank air cooled and high horse power liquid cooled engines. If they could have built the equivalent of a B-29 they also could have built the equivalent of Hellcats, Corsairs,P-38s, and P-47s. To get the strategic use out of a B-29 would require a base at a range equivalent to what what we achieved. The capacity to build a B-29 would have had more effect on the war than the actual building of one in my guess.
Posted by: The Brickmuppet at July 19, 2009 07:35 PM (Vn+9Y)
13
What would the Japanese have done with heavy bombers?
They turned out to be mos' unsuitable for attacking vessels at sea, despite pre-war claims to the contrary. And as far as supporting attack operations, there simply weren't any Pacific island targets that Japan failed to take because of on-land defenses (if we discount New Guinea, and that was just jungle attrition.)
The nastiest use of them would have been against US beachheads or airfields (not that Henderson Field would have been an easy target, but you wouldn't have to hit it a whole lot...)
If anything, the diversion of scarce pilots and manufacturing resources into heavy bombers probably would have weakened Japanese air assets overall, and the fuel situation in mid-1944 to the end of the war pretty much precluded large-scale bomber operations anyway.
Without the ability to get air bases within range of US centers of production (many of which were inconveniently located thousands of miles EAST of the West Coast), there's not really any suitable strategic bombing targets for Japan to hit.
Mentioning the fuel situation brings up a good "what if", I think. We know that the Japanese had next to no antisubmarine warfare units, despite having what were arguably the finest destroyers in the world. How much difference would it have made if the Japanese had pulled some of those destroyers back for convoy duty? (Could they have done it, though? The morale effect on the companies of those destroyers would have been disastrous - even if the Naval Staff had appreciated the need, the crews would not have taken it well...)
If Go Nagai had directed Evangelion, it would have been made of win and God, with an extra side helping of holy crap!
Posted by: Avatar at July 20, 2009 02:28 AM (vGfoR)
Late in the war, they could have used heavy bombers against Iwo, and in particular against the American ground operations on Luzon and Okinawa.
But by that point the war was essentially lost for Japan; it was just a matter of time and expense. I can't see a B-29 equivalent making any game-changing difference before that.
The Remains Of The Day
As I mentioned back on Wednesday, the Duck U. Bookstore received its Fall shipment of used textbooks, totaling 130 boxes and nearly two tons of weight. None of these boxes were particularly well-filled, so there was a lot of shredded cardboard used as packing material. How much?
This much:
Mt Trashmore, scaled by duckie
By the time we had all the boxes opened, the pile was about four feet tall and about seven feet across at the base. Now, I'm just a duck with an uncanny ability to pack boxes well (called "box origami" or "pack-fu" in the store), but you'd think that you could just fill the boxes with, y'know, textbooksand ship fewer boxes. But what do I know?
I DO know that all that packing material ended up in the dumpster, which took five trips. Bloody waste, that's all that is. I knew I shouldn't've worn black...
Of course, I'm cheating because I know the billing schedule. It's by weight, so 4000 lbs in 80 boxes is charged the same amount as 4000 lbs in 130 boxes. In fact, all that packing material just makes the shipping costs HIGHER, because it weighs a non-trivial amount.
Posted by: Wonderduck at July 17, 2009 05:27 PM (ZpwKm)
SeaBass, a four-time consecutive driver's champion in ChampCar, ran 27 races in F1, earning a total of six points. He had two seventh place finishes in 2008, and two eighth place finishes this season. Meanwhile, his teammates have consistently outscored him. Last year, Sebastien Vettel scored 35 points, including the team's first victory and 9 total points-paying finishes. This year, rookie Sebastian Buemi has three points. Of course, other than the points scored, SeaBass has outperformed Buemi in finishing position.
Still, for someone with his obvious driving talent, SeaBass has been a disappointment, though perhaps Toro Rosso has pulled the trigger a little too fast. SeaBass is threatening legal action for breach of contract.
The team has not yet named a replacement, but it's widely assumed that third driver Jaime Alguersuari will be given the drive. If so, he'll become the youngest driver in F1 history at 19 years, 125 days at the Hungarian Grand Prix.
Endless 8: a reply
(Over at Chizumatic, Steven has put up a post regarding the continuing saga of the second season of Haruhi Suzumiya. For those who don't know, the past four episodes have taken place in a time-loop, replaying the same two week timeframe. Kyoto Animation has reanimated each episode so everything is visually different, and while the dialogue is mostly the same, it isn't completely.
And there's been a huge uproar by various people over how annoying this is. I've been steaming about this uproar for a couple of weeks now; Steven's post just pushed me over the edge. This was going to be a comment over there, but I decided to make it a post here instead.) There isn't anything clever about this. It just shows utter contempt for the fans.
I completely and totally disagree. I think it's experimental, very
inventive, and quite fascinating to watch. Trying to see how they're
going to make it different this time, how much closer they're coming to
breaking the loop (don't let anybody tell you different, Kyon & Co.
are coming closer)... it's been quite entertaining to me. Certainly better than Generic Harem Comedy & The Sword of Power, iteration #83.
I just don't get why people are complaining... you wanted Haruhi 2: The Wrath of Kyon,
now it's here. There was no way it could possibly live up to the
expectations of those people who thought everything else should be put
on hold until KyoAni made it. Now that it's running, and it's not all
Unicorns farting rainbows, it's immediately marked down as the worst
thing EVAR.
I call bullhocky on that. Is it as good as the first season? No, no
it isn't. Is it offensive and contemptable? No, no it isn't. Would I
like to see "Endless 8" end? Yes, I would, but saying that KyoAni is
disrespecting the fans because it hasn't ended is ridiculous. So you don't like the plot loop. Fine; I wasn't fond of the length of the Makoto arc in Kanon 2006, either, but that doesn't make it crap, or "poor judgement," or whatever.
Perhaps I'm the iconoclast here, because I'm enjoying the show. So be it. Wouldn't be the first time, won't be the last.
UPDATE: Yes, this is how much KyoAni disrespects the fans. The setup is that the SOS Brigade visits a Bon Festival, and Yuki decides to buy a mask. Here's what the scene looks like in the first episode of "Endless 8":
In the second episode, this is how the scene appears:
Third time around:
...and fourth:
Yes, in all four episodes, she's buying a mask. But every time, KyoAni has given us a different look and feel to the scene. The masks are different, Yuki's kimono is different, the camera angle is different, and while you can't tell from these shots, her body language is different. Which, considering that in the storyline, she remembers every detail of every loop (over 15000, which works out to nearly 600 years), makes perfect sense.
Every single episode is presented like this; everything is the same, but completely different. If that's a lack of imagination from KyoAni and contempt for the viewer, then I'll take their contempt every single day of the week. It's still better than most of the crap out there right now.
3
...and that's where the disagreement is. I'm enjoying "Endless 8", and quite a bit, to boot. There's enough different in every episode that it's stayed completely fresh for me, and the dramatic tension in knowing what's going on, while the characters don't, is interesting as well.
Posted by: Wonderduck at July 16, 2009 09:31 PM (NSDDW)
Posted by: Wonderduck at July 16, 2009 10:41 PM (NSDDW)
5
Technically, they're doing it right, no argument there. But in a 14 episode season, nearly half of the them have the exact same storyline, one right after another. Visually different, but the general plot and pacing are the same. And after three years of waiting for a second season, this is a huge let down. Maybe ducks have more tolerance for minutia than I have.
Posted by: John Smith at July 16, 2009 10:56 PM (sDvZi)
6
Mr Smith, I submit that just about anything would have been a letdown. As I mentioned before, the amount of hype surrounding Haruhi I and the screaming for Haruhi II was so huge that there was no way that this series could have been considered a success for KyoAni.
Except for those who ignored the hype, took the first season for what it was (a very good show, but not the 'greatest anime ever', as some proclaimed it), and simply waited for them to bring it out when they wanted.
Given KyoAni's track record, I think they deserve the benefit of the doubt.
Posted by: Wonderduck at July 16, 2009 11:27 PM (NSDDW)
7
Thank you, Wonderduck, I could not agree more with everything you say in this post. The Endless Eight is rich and imaginative in its small but distinguishable changes, and I for one (not a Haruhi fangirl) am enjoying it. Do I want it to end? Sure, eventually. But I'm okay with the Endless Eight spanning eight episodes. Every new episode builds up more tension, so that we're approaching Yuki's state of mind as an "observer". I find this interesting and different, and it honestly keeps me entertained.
Also, and I don't know how much truth there is in this, I've heard that this season will be longer than originally planned. In which case fans need not cry on that front.
Posted by: bucklemyshoe at July 17, 2009 06:21 AM (KFbf0)
8
The time-loop idea is a favorite amongst writers. It looks like Kyoani is trying to execute it differently than the traditional method.
By "traditional method" I mean the way the second time through the loop is usually shown in full detail right up to the reset. Each successive loop is shown in less and less detail, focusing in only on the key events (usually degrading down to a quick montage of one event repeated in its continuing variations from each loop), until the final breakout gets treated in full length. It's meant to give the audience the sense of futile maddening repetition without sending them through the whole thing X times and actually maddening them. (But you could argue they're attempting to do just that: put the audience through the experience.)
Kyoani looks to be floating a trial-balloon to see how audiences would respond to a different method of handling a classic trope. It appears that people generally enjoy the old way of doing business.
9
The reason people are complaining is that what they WANTED was the Book 4 story, and this isn't it. ;p Endless Eight is cute, but it's the lettuce on the burger, not the meat.
Posted by: Avatar_exADV at July 17, 2009 02:58 PM (pWQz4)
10
I have to ditto Wonderduck here, too. I have really enjoyed the Endless Eight sequence. I find it suspenseful, and I love watching each episode to see what's going to be different. I think KyoAni tried something different, and unfortunately not everyone likes it.
Posted by: Xinem at July 17, 2009 05:05 PM (5RyMk)
One interesting way out of this mess would be to skip the original (fairly weak) ending and segue right into /Disappearance/ - Yuki's boredom having finally induced her to do something drastic. It isn't canon but then this arc isn't hewing too closely to the book anyway.
Posted by: mparker762 at July 17, 2009 11:15 PM (+tKOX)
Interesting argument. I've always though the reason S2 has taken so long is that Kyoani have been terrified of an Star Wars Episode 1 like backlash- whatvever it could live up to the hype.
Now there attitude seems to be 'You want something to complain about? We'll give you something to complain about!'
Posted by: Andy Janes at July 18, 2009 02:07 AM (lNf10)