June 04, 2013
Even the books from the first category, such as Gordon Prange's Miracle at Midway, have substantial value. Ironically, the weakest book of the bunch is the very first: Fuchida's. It has been made clear through ongoing research, both here and in Japan, that he played fast and loose with the truth. Well, that's unfortunate, but the truth appears to have come out.
I haven't completed Dallas Isom's book, so I can't say what I think of it yet. What I've read has managed to furrow my brow a few times... not always in a good way, it must be said. It's certainly been worth the $4.95 I spent on it, though.
Of course, I forgot to put my newest addition in the picture... it's sitting on my dining room table. I haven't read it yet; it's going to be my business trip reading in a couple of weeks.
I wonder if any other single battle has generated as many books as Midway has? D-Day, probably, but that isn't really a single battle, is it? The Battle of Britain, likely... except that was less a battle and more of a campaign. Maybe Stalingrad... but probably not.
And that's how it should be.
It appears a big reason why Mitsuo Fuchida has been such a major influence on both accounts of both Midway and Pearl Harbor was because he deliver his accounts in English direct to the US audience.
I do think Stalingrad has generated more books than Midway, but Stalingrad might be regarded as a campaign as well, if you look beyond the battle for the city. The main difference is that most of the books on Stalingrad are published in either German or Russian, which can skew the number.
Posted by: cxt217 at June 04, 2013 07:48 PM (El3Kr)
Posted by: Steven Den Beste at June 05, 2013 06:55 AM (+rSRq)
Gettysburg 7539 (2043 probable valid, in "Military History")
Antietam 1743 (651 probable valid, in "Military History")
Waterloo 6051 (473 probable valid, in "Military History")
Midway 2443 (230 probable valid, in "Military History")
Stalingrad 1399 (476 probable valid, in "Military History")
D-Day 212351 (9666 probable valid, in "Military History")
Dien Bien Phu 2623 (850 probable valid, in "Military History")
I think D-Day takes it, with Gettysburg a distant second.
Posted by: Mitch H. at June 05, 2013 07:59 AM (jwKxK)
Posted by: Steven Den Beste at June 05, 2013 03:03 PM (+rSRq)
Midway is really, really not going to win the romance category, unless we start having American magical girl historical romance as a major subgenre. It's got a chance with historical fiction and what-if sf, though.
Posted by: Suburbanbanshee at June 06, 2013 10:33 PM (cvXSV)
Posted by: Mitch H. at June 07, 2013 07:08 AM (jwKxK)
Dien Bien Phu might have a lock on the romance category, given that the French fortified positions were named after the commander's many mistresses...
And like most romantic legends, probably false.
Posted by: cxt217 at June 07, 2013 10:49 AM (XnzqV)
47 queries taking 0.1499 seconds, 245 records returned.
Powered by Minx 1.1.6c-pink.