Wonderduck's Favorite Anime Series Of All Time: Number Three
A favorite show needs to transport you to a different place than your own reality. That's one of the advantages of the art of animation in general and anime in particular. Anything you can imagine, and most things that you couldn't, are not only possible, but easy to do. Giant mecha striding confidently across flaming terrain. Enormous battleships rising out of the ocean to do battle with massive alien fleets. Martial artists that make Bruce Lee look like a newborn infant. Magical energy blasts powerful enough to destroy skyscrapers, called forth by girls in elementary school. Heroes and heroines of every shape and size, saving the world from the most evil of opponents. All of these are entertaining, exciting... and commonplace in anime. To be truly different, a show needs to be outstanding not only in plot and character, but in setting, and not be afraid to tell its story the way it needs to be told, no matter how unlikely it may sound.
Even if the story is that of female gondolieri on Mars.
Wonderduck's Favorite Anime Series Of All Time: Number Four
A favorite show should be one of those things that fits like a good pair of shoes or well broken-in jeans... comfortable. You should be able to put on any episode and immediately sink into the backstory like you'd watched everything up to that point in a marathon. Perhaps it's a seminal moment in your fandom, or something that made the whole concept of what a good anime could do click for you. In short, a favorite show should be part of you as an anime fan. Coming in at Number Four on my list is an epically grand story involving secret societies, spans multiple continents, and the whole of the history of Western Civilization, yet at its heart is about nothing more than two young women.
This is an absolutely excellent choice, and I understand it both being on the list and not being at the top. Great write-up, sir.
Kirika. The template for any number of "quiet young assassin girls" both in Bee Train sequels and elsewhere. Rarely surpassed, and it's a characterization that works better when you haven't seen it done thirty times already. If you come to Noir after seeing those others... well, detach the "oh god not this again" part of your brain. She may not have been the first, but still.
Chloe. An antagonist who manages to be devious, sinister, creepy, and an honorable opponent all at once. (I don't think I'm spoilering, here. All I'm saying is that she's a great character!)
Mirelle has the thankless job of being our main point-of-view character, the one with the least idea what's going on, and our vehicle for figuring it all out. She is what she is, eh?
I would say that even if Noir isn't a must-own series for anyone who's really getting into anime, I'd say it's a must-see. I watch it through every few years, and other than "no no no not 'Melodie' AGAIN" (see also: "ah, an action sequence must be coming up because the music says so") it's always a pleasure.
Posted by: GreyDuck at December 12, 2010 09:58 AM (7lMXI)
2Noir is one of my favorite animes. However, as much as I liked how they used the flashback of the watch scene, and how you slowly saw more and more of the scene, then in the end saw the same scene from another POV, I think they over-used it a bit.
I found myself starting to tune it out after awhile, even though I knew that every couple episodes they'd reveal a little bit more of the flashback scene. Maybe if they'd showed the flashback in fewer episodes, so I didn't have a chance to memorize it so well...
Posted by: Siergen at December 12, 2010 02:44 PM (Gqqsw)
3
I hereby register my prediction: #2 will be Azumanga Daioh, and #1 will be the Aria franchise.
Posted by: Steven Den Beste at December 12, 2010 03:45 PM (+rSRq)
4
Great show. The dub has one of my favorite dark humor moments, when Mirielle tells Kirika, "You work is just so... garish."
The slow pacing adds to the overall feeling of malevolence that is always behind the scenes.
Posted by: skyhack at December 12, 2010 10:41 PM (R3PHF)
5
I thoroughly enjoyed working on this show. Not only did it come at the perfect time (right after I'd finished Excel Saga), but it was a show where the lack of dialogue really challenged us to make it count, as it were. We spent a lot of time talking about how to phrase this or that, so that we'd get exactly the same kind of connotation or ambiguity that it had in the Japanese. Shoko knocked it completely out of the park. (I do, however, take credit for the poetry.)
There were a couple of low-budget episodes (I'm particularly thinking of 16, the Hong Kong one... there were a couple spots in the fight scene where people were pretty badly off-model and without any of the usual fluidity or choreography that you'd come to expect from the rest of the show.) But overall it worked, and worked well.
The music was inspired. I'll still listen to the soundtrack from time to time. The best of Kajiura's work that I ever saw, to be sure.
Not EVERYONE loved it. But if you were going to like that kind of show, where you had mixed intrigue and gunplay, you never saw anything better than Noir. Even Bebop, which also had fantastic music and great production values, isn't quite as good.
And the hidden sock puppet theater... I still can't believe we actually filmed it and included it. Or more like, how in the nine hells did we get permission from the Japanese? (DID we get permission?) I actually hurt something laughing, the first time I saw it...
Posted by: Avatar_exADV at December 12, 2010 11:37 PM (mRjOr)
Funny story about that. I worked for the university doing tech support while I was finishing up my degree. My co-worker AJ had some bootleg copies of Noir and was watching them, paused it at one point and asked me if I'd seen it. Coincidentally he paused it... during the credits... when my name was on the screen. I pointed...
Posted by: Avatar at December 13, 2010 05:03 PM (pWQz4)
9
I agree with Steven's predictions. I'm going to take a wild guess that the remaining series is Elfen Lied.
Posted by: Don at December 13, 2010 06:46 PM (utUGf)
10
I have to admit to being one of the heathens who don't like this series. Love the music, and I'm not generally opposed to the overall storyline, but I felt as if I had seen everything in this show before, not just Kirika. Most love the pacing; I thought it was incredibly slow and boring. My first thought after finishing the last episode was, "That's it?!?"
Noir is one of the few series that I have to just flat out admit that I apparently just don't get it.
But great music. Oh yeah.
Posted by: Ben at December 13, 2010 09:55 PM (gze3w)
11
A laconic story about fate, friendship and forgiveness where every single frame exudes melancholy...yet, where the closing frames still manage to convey some true hopefulness. Its pacing and structure are clearly not for everyone, but to me, at least, Noir is one of the most moving works of fiction I've ever come across -- a stirring paean to the power of friendship.
Now we just have to hope that Starz doesn't ruin it turning it into a TV show!
Posted by: DP at January 01, 2011 07:14 AM (YvG5/)
Wonderduck's Favorite Anime Series Of All Time: The Honorable Mentions
What makes a favorite a favorite? Ask that question to a dozen people and you'll likely get a dozen different answers. But just as everybody who watches anime has favorite shows, they'll also have some series that fall just short of that lofty goal, and I'm hardly an exception to this rule. So before I get into my true favorite series, it's time to look at those that just don't make the cut. Understand, all of these shows are quite good but have a shortcoming or two that keep it from making it to the top of the heap: Wonderduck's Favorite Anime Series Of All Time. Without further ado, in no particular order here's the slightly not-as-great shows!
(Image from Toshokan Sensou, which didn't even make the Honorable Mentions list)
1
My real problem with Hidamari Sketch (in its various iterations) isn't even that nothing happens in the show. I'm fine with that; the characters are engaging and I don't mind spending time with them.
It's just that they do all kinds of stupid things with the artwork. Okay, using real textures in an animated production occasionally will work; but not when you do it all the damn time.
In fact, all the artsy stuff they do ends up being a serious distraction, and I end up wondering if the point behind the animation is to show how artistically complex they can make it, rather than to tell the story of a few girls living in the same apartment building. That's why I don't enjoy it as much as I otherwise would.
Posted by: Ed Hering at December 11, 2010 12:34 AM (Dh1KI)
2
I couldn't get too far into GSG:IT, due to the horrid downgrade of production quality between the two series. I'd read the manga so I knew the (quite good) story, and this is one of the few cases where I didn't really care to see how the anime portrayed it further. (Usually I prefer the animated medium.)
You're spot on about GSG, though. A well told tale about a downer, somewhat squicky premise.
I keep meaning to finish F/SN... taken two stabs at watching and keep falling off before the halfway point. Sigh.
Posted by: GreyDuck at December 11, 2010 01:13 AM (7lMXI)
3
Ga-Rei Zero didn't make the top four?!? But...but...it's got Laser Weasels and Pocky sticks! And two girls eating Pocky sticks in the back of a Hummer!
Posted by: Siergen at December 11, 2010 01:05 PM (Gqqsw)
4
F/SN just has three storylines, and unlike a lot of games where it's just "which girl do you end up with", the stories are pretty radically different. Archer is almost completely missing from the Fate storyline path, but the UBW path is all Archer all the time; the Heaven's Feel path is a ghastly nightmare of continual rape that I don't even WANT to play through.
You couldn't possibly integrate all three into the same TV series (other than Higurashi-style, but this was before that aired). So the TV series did the Fate storyline but threw some other stuff in there, mostly to keep some of the secondary characters from being purely "extras". It was... not really an improvement; the show could have been a much more tightly-paced 13 or 14 episodes and done quite well.
Posted by: Avatar_exADV at December 11, 2010 03:45 PM (mRjOr)
5
I think I have a pretty good idea what the top four are, now that you've eliminated HidaSketch. Still looking forward to finding out, though.
Posted by: Andrew F. at December 11, 2010 04:42 PM (OVQR0)
6
You might guess three of them, Andrew, but I'm pretty sure that nobody will guess the fourth.
Posted by: Wonderduck at December 11, 2010 05:28 PM (vW/MM)
(Completely) Random Anime Picture #59 -Strike Witches 1st Series, ep04
As I'm currently working on a series of posts, tentatively titled "Wonderduck's Favorite Anime Series Of All Time," and can't be bothered to come up with something clever today, here's a picture of Gertrud Barkhorn from a series that isn't on the list, Strike Witches the first season, which is a perfectly acceptable show, but doesn't make it onto the short list of my favorite anime series of all time, and thus I end this run-on sentence.
By "(Completely) Random," I mean it. I used a totally impartial random number generator in Virginia to give me the number of a folder I have sitting on my external hard drive, then chose an episode by waving the mouse over the episodes contained therein with my eyes closed. Then I chose a spot in the episode, also at random, and voila! A Barkhorn appears. Enjoy!
Megane no Kanojo OVA
In this day and age of anime otakudom, the internet gives you just about anything you could possibly want to ever want to know about every show that's running, has run, or is going to be coming down the pike. It has also given us the chance to dislike shows even before we see them, and to tell everybody that the shows are awful weeks before they hit the air. Every season it has become routine to hear the call of "worst season ever!" These calls are never right. There are always shows that come from out of nowhere that sound horrible but turn out to be decent, good, or occasionally even great. It is therefore rare that something sneaks through the vast web of bloggers, websites and twitterfeeds until it is actually released. I don't consider myself particularly plugged in to the Great Horde, but yet I still seem to know a little bit about just about everything that's coming out every season.
Which is why the Megane no Kanojo OVA has come as such a surprise to me, and I suspect quite a few others... I heard nothing about it prior to the day someone subbed it. That's a shame, because in this time when cynicism about everything anime is de rigueur, this little show is quite a breath of fresh air. The OVA consists of four unrelated short (around 10-12 minutes running time without the OP and ED) episodes about, as you may have guessed from the title, girls who wear glasses. As of the time this is written, UTW has released two of the episodes.
The first one is about the Sempai of a high school Literature Club, and the boy who joins because he saw her without glasses once and thought she was cute. Shocked and horrified by the fact that she wears glasses constantly, he then spends a year trying to get her to take them off, just once... until she discovers that his eyesight is horrible. Hijinks ensue.
The second episode is about "Japan's most popular Idol." In her time off, she puts on a pair of glasses, a different hairstyle, and a floppy cap as a disguise, then sits in a coffeehouse and relaxes... until the day that one of the waiters asks her out. They go on a date, while she frets the entire time that he knows who she is... until she figures out that he really has no clue, then she frets about the fact that he doesn't know.
There's no way in the world that I'd claim that Megane no Kanojo is a great show. The art isn't particularly good, the two stories so far aren't particularly deep (to be fair, there's only so much you can do in 10 minutes), the characters are basically stock, and on and on. But yet, they're refreshing. There's no pretensions towards great art here, just short stories that are entertaining, friendly and fun. Ten minutes is about the right length for them; shorter and you won't get around to actually liking the characters, longer and the amount of story the plots can support would run out. The production team clearly understood this and did the best they could under the constraints they had. The results turned out pretty good. Heck, I had a smile on my face after I watched each one, and what more could you hope for from a show like this?
REAL First Snow! In contrast to the dusting we had a couple days ago, last night Duckford was hit by a real snowfall. No totals yet, but the predictions were for 4"-8". My guess is that we probably had five inches, at least around Pond Central. It's not a wet, heavy snow, which is nice. Slippery, though. Last night around 1130pm, I was returning from a pleasant evening of conversation with Dr John, who is the father of reader-and-occasional-commenter Vaucaunson's Duck. At one point I was stuck behind an idiot who didn't know how to climb a slightly steep grade in a rear-wheel drive car... at least, I was stuck behind him until he fishtailed himself into a curb. *shakes head* Right up until he clonked the curb his rear tires were a blur. Obviously the driver was a believer in the Jeremy Clarkson method: "MORE POWER!!!" Idiot.
1
OMGosh! Snow already! That means it's not too long before it arrives over here on the east coast. Brrrrrr. That duck is gonna need a scarf or something so it doesn't catch a cold or the bird flu
Haha. Cute pic as always! Stay warm!
Posted by: Digicolleen at December 04, 2010 11:51 AM (y3twI)
2
We didn't get as much down here. Maybe 3 inches.
One night--back when I lived in Cedar Rapids--we'd had an ice storm and everything was coated with ice, including the roads. I was watching TV, but kept hearing this weird noise from outside; it went on and on for several minutes, and finally it annoyed me enough to go see what the hell it was.
Some guy, out in the street, was trying to get his RWD car (I think it was a mid-80s Buick Regal) moving on the ice, and he seemed to think that if he stood on the gas and spun the tire (open differential FTL) as fast as possible, that would get him moving.
You'd think that after a few minutes of this the guy would twig to the notion that this isn't going to work and might try something else; but no, it went on like this for quite a while.
The sound eventually went away. I don't know if the guy grenaded his drivetrain or what.
Posted by: Ed Hering at December 04, 2010 01:59 PM (Dh1KI)
For Sale, Slightly Used
As the DuckMobile is pushing 15 years of age, I've been looking for a replacement. This involves a lot of head-shaking on my part as I can't really afford anything these days, but occasionally there's a "For Sale" ad that's hard to ignore... to whit:
MUST GO, ALL OFFERS CONSIDERED! 30 years old, needs work but in decent shape. Good mileage. In stock.
Posted by: Wonderduck at December 03, 2010 12:16 AM (vW/MM)
3
I don't have any jets that can take off from a jump deck. Fleet carriers only!
It did good service in the Falklands War, indeed. If not for the CAP provided by those Harriers, the Argentine air force would have had a much better time of things. On the other hand, it's arguable that the Invincible was worth more than the entirety of the Falklands; certainly the British nightmare scenario was "Exocet takes out the carrier". (They DID lose the Atlantic Conveyor, their big cargo transport, along with most of the force's transport helicopters on board...)
Posted by: Avatar at December 03, 2010 12:30 AM (pWQz4)
Don't get me started on our new coalition overlords decision to retired the Ark and the Harriers (the air to air Sea Harriers went ages ago btw, only the RAF's ground attack version was left).
Hopefully there won't be a need for a naval air support until the new carriers (minus aircraft!) arrive later this decade...
Posted by: Andy Janes at December 03, 2010 02:46 AM (KBzPM)
5
Are you kidding? $5 says the electrical system came from Lucas Electrics.
Posted by: Ed Hering at December 03, 2010 03:01 PM (Dh1KI)
Why does that need a name? Is there anyone who doesn't fear ducks?
Well, ducks don't fear ducks, as far as I know...
Posted by: Siergen at December 03, 2010 10:55 PM (Gqqsw)
10
Tony, that's good, but I prefer anatidaephobia: the fear that somewhere, somehow, a duck is watching you. (with thanks to Gary Larson)
Posted by: Wonderduck at December 04, 2010 12:31 AM (vW/MM)
11
No bet, Steven. (At least if we're talking about jet carriers. Wouldn't be surprised if they built a heli "carrier"...)
Posted by: Avatar_exADV at December 04, 2010 03:57 AM (mRjOr)
12
I'll take that bet Steven, though the only reason we're getting at least one is because it was cheaper to build than cancel the contracts (which I still can't quite get my head round)
Posted by: Andy Janes at December 04, 2010 07:36 AM (vu1Y2)
13
Andy, IANAL, but I have seem some contracts which contain rather harsh
cancellation clauses. If you're ordering something that the other guy
will need spend a lot of upfront money to produce (build a factory,
construct custom tooling, pre-order unique parts, etc.), then they want
assurances that they won't get screwed if you change your mind.
If you have a prior reputation for canceling big orders (like say,
Britain's MoD), then you may need to really pad the cancellation clauses
to get them to bid on the contract. Afterall, they are not bidding on other projects because they anticipate being busy with your work.
Posted by: Siergen at December 04, 2010 06:25 PM (Gqqsw)
First Snow! Okay yes, the correct term for the snow we had today would be "a dusting," but it still was snowfall, and it did stick around. And I did have to brush it off the DuckMobile, so I don't care what anybody says, that was an official snowfall. Throw in the sub-20°F ambient temperatures and the gusty winds and you had yourself an ickycoldbad day.
And in a month we'll be saying "remember a few weeks ago, when it was 20 degrees and there wasn't any snow on the ground? Ah, it was warm then!" But today, I kinda wish I had Snowbird's earmuffs...